How Allstate Has Earned Billions by Shortchanging Policyholders

Updated on: 3/20/2019

The book, "From Good Hands to Boxing Gloves: The Dark Side of Insurance" (2008) by David J. Berardinelli, discusses how Allstate revolutionized the claims handling process by implementing policies to deliberately reduce benefits and claim payouts by intentionally paying out less than the true value of the claim. 

Mr. Berardinelli states that our insurance system is founded on two key rules: the indemnity principle and the fiduciary principle. Together these principles are intended to level the playing field between the insurance company and the policyholder. 

These principles balance the insurer’s legitimate goal of being profitable while allowing the insured policyholders to get prompt and fair payment for covered losses.

How Auto Insurance Is Different

Mr. Berardinelli states that casualty insurance is a unique insurance product. It’s different from other kinds of insurance like life insurance. Life insurance pays a set benefit when you die regardless of the cause or consequences of your death.

But casualty insurance is indemnity coverage. It doesn’t pay a set benefit. It pays as much as the policyholder needs, up to the policy’s limit, "to restore an insured to the same financial position after the loss that he or she was in prior to the loss." 

To indemnify someone means to make them whole again. That means the insured doesn’t get paid more than the actual loss. It also means the insured shouldn’t get paid less than what it takes to make the insured whole again.

The insurance company's duty is to pay the full amount the policy holder needs to be put back in the same position he or she was in before the loss.  This is called the indemnity principle.

Allstate Turns Focus To Squeezing Claimants

Mr. Bernadelli states that Allstate implemented a program to intentionally pay out less than the true value of claims.  Essentially, Allstate intentionally violated the indemnity principle, leaving policyholders and claimants much less than the insurance coverage they were entitled to receive.

How did Allstate accomplish this?  Well Allstate often deliberately delays paying legitimate claims by asking for useless information or demanding more proof than it really needs. It would delay payment or force policyholders to jump through needless hoops, in hopes they’ll give up or take less than the full and fair amount of the benefits they’re owed under the policy.

Allstate paid for studies which showed that nearly 85% of claimants would accept whatever lowball offer Allstate made, and not bother with the hassle.  When you are talking about hundreds of thousands of claims, this adds up to hundreds of millions saved for Allstate.

Quick Payout Tactics Pay Off For Allstate

Another tactic Allstate uses is to pressure policyholders who are in a financial bind into accepting a quick payment that’s far less than what they need to make them whole. It forces policyholders to file needless, expensive, and time consuming lawsuits as the only way to get what they need to fully restore them to where they were before the loss.

Again, Allstate found that most people will not bother to go through the hassle of hiring a lawyer and filing a lawsuit. More money saved for Allstate.

Mr. Bernadelli found that Allstate repeatedly violated the important principles which are necessary to protect people who purchase insurance.  Yet Allstate continues to get away with its tactics.  Allstate continues to put its own financial interests ahead of their insured’s needs, and now the system is no longer fair.

The playing field is no longer level and an insured either accepts less than they receive or seeks legal counsel to level the field.

Contact Our Insurance Dispute Lawyers

The award-winning insurance dispute lawyers at Davis Law Group have helped accident victims get fair compensation for their injuries for more than 25 years. We can help you better understand your rights and determine if hiring an attorney may increase your chances of receiving fair compensation.

Call our office in Seattle or contact us via the online contact form on this page to request a free legal consultation with the award-winning personal injury lawyers at Davis Law Group.

Chris Davis
Attorney Chris Davis is the founder of Seattle-based Davis Law Group, P.S.
Be the first to comment!
Post a Comment